Zero narcissism. Phenomenon of Boris Yudin
Zero narcissism. Phenomenon of Boris Yudin
Read   Download pdf

The article is a specially version of the text “Instead of the Conclusion” from the forthcoming book “Narcissus in Armor. Psychopathology of “grandiose Self” in politics and power” (M.: Progress-Tradition, 2019) reworked by the author for the journal “Chelovek”. The urgency of the problem is justified by the multiple symptoms and consequences of narcissistic deviations in politics, the mass consciousness and the collective unconscious with an emphasis on Russian reality. The conclusion about such deviations is made on the basis of comparison with the lists of symptoms of standard diagnostics, including the DSM-5. Fixation on own grandiosity and omnipotence, imaginary greatness, abnormal desire to put oneself in the spotlight, tendency to exploit and manipulativeness, lack of empathy and intolerance towards criticism with explosions of narcissistic rage are being marked. Against the background of a characteristic for Russia mass ignorance of narcissism epidemics in the modern world, and particularly in the recent decades, it is being shown the psychological reason for narcissistic counterattacks aimed to keep the issue solely within the framework of ordinary logic and competence. The formula “zero narcissism” is introduced as a psychoanalytic and therapeutic setting associated with the need to block the automatic competition and narcissistic provocations of the patient, to track own effects of analytical grandeur and therapeutic power. The problem of the “zero of narcissism” is investigated not only at the level of theory and methodology, but also empirically, using the example of a specific psychotype. Such an example is presented in an anthropological analysis of the “Boris Yudin phenomenon” — the founder and former editor-in-chief of the journal “Chelovek” (in 1999 – 2017). Synthesis of theoretical and methodological analysis with a specific case description helps to coordinate theory and stable everyday ideas. Such work in the zone "close to the zero" opens up an opportunity to correspond and partly to combine different versions and scales of normal, pathological and malignant narcissism, taking into consideration its destructive and constructive accentuation.

About authors

1. Komte O. Obshchii obzor pozitivizma. GL. XIV [A general view of positivism. Chapter XIV]. Rodonachal'niki pozitivizma. Vyp. 4–5. [Fathers of positivism. Iss. 4–5]. St. Petersburg: Brokgauz i Efron Publ., 1912. P. 116 –172.

2. Malevich K.S. Sobranie sochinenij: v 5 t. [Collected Works: in 5 vol.]. Moscow: Gileya Publ., 1995.

3. Malevich o sebe. Sovremenniki o Maleviche. Pis'ma. Dokumenty. Vospominaniya. Kritika: v 2 t. [Malevich about himself. Contemporaries about Maleviche. The letters. Documents. Memories. Criticism: in 2 vol.]. Vol. 1. Moscow: RA Publ., 2004. P. 66.

4. Meshcheryakov A.N. Imperator Mehidzi i ego Yaponiya [Emperor Meiji and his Japan]. Moscow: Natalis Publ., 2009. URL: (date of access: 30.04.2019).

5. Mlodik I.Yu. Poka ty pytalsya stat' bogom... Muchitel'nyi put' nartsissa [While you're trying to become a God. The painful path of narcissus]. Moscow: Genezis Publ., 2009. URL: (date of access: 30.04.2019).

6. Ovid (Publius Ovidius Naso). Lyubovnye ehlegii. Metamorfozy. Skorbnye ehlegii [Love Elegies. Metamorphosis. Mournful Elegies]. Moscow: Khudozhestvennaya literatura Publ., 1983.

7. Rubtsov A.V. Ideologi i nartsissy. Mify vsemogushchestva: retsidivy, obostreniya, epidemii [Ideologists and narcissuses. Myths of omnipotence: relapses, aggravations, epidemics]. Filosofiya i ideologiya: ot Marksa do postmoderna [Philosophy and ideology: from Marx to postmodernity]. Moscow: Progress-Traditsiya, 2018. P. 147–168.

8. Rubtsov A.V. Ideologia i nartsissizm. Manii grandioznosti: nablyudenie, simptomatika, genezis [Ideology and narcissism. Manias for grandiosity: observation, symptomatics, genesis]. Filosofiya i ideologiya: ot Marksa do postmoderna [Philosophy and ideology: from Marx to postmodernity]. Moscow: Progress-Traditsiya, 2018. P. 130–146.

9. Yudin B.G. Chelovek: vykhod za predely [Human being: moving beyond the limits]. Moscow: Progress-Traditsiya, 2018.

10. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5). Arlington: American Psychiatric Publishing, 2013.

11. Franzoso E. Is Narcissism the Same as Egocentrism? Thriveglobal, 2019, April 9. [Electronic resource] URL: (date of access: 30.04.2019).

Полная версия доступна только подписчикам
Подпишитесь прямо сейчас